Wednesday, 25 Jun 2025
Latest Videos!
Repute Today Repute Today
  • India
  • News
  • World
    • United States
  • Business
  • Entertainment
  • Politics
  • Lifestyle
    • Food
    • Fashion
    • Travel
  • Sports
  • Technology
  • More
    • Events
    • Opinions
Reading: Alabama IVF Treatments: Governor signs IVF protection bill into law, but experts say it will take more work to protect fertility services.
Share
  • Trending Topics -
  • United States
  • India
  • News
  • Health
  • Sports
  • World
  • Entertainment
  • Business
  • Food
  • Donald Trump
Repute TodayRepute Today
Font ResizerAa
  • Home
  • Events
  • Sports
  • Viral
  • Opinions
Search
  • Categories
    • United States
    • Events
    • Lifestyle
    • Entertainment
    • Sports
    • Travel
    • Technology
    • Biography
Follow US
© 2025 Repute Today. All Rights Reserved.
News

Alabama IVF Treatments: Governor signs IVF protection bill into law, but experts say it will take more work to protect fertility services.

Alabama lawmakers set to finalize IVF legislation, but experts say it's going to take more work to protect fertility services. Isabel Rosales.

Last updated: March 7, 2024 12:37 PM
By Published March 7, 2024
Share
Pregnant Woman
SHARE

Montgomery, Alabama — Alabama Gov. Kay Ivey signed a bill into law aimed at protecting in vitro fertilization patients and providers from legal liability late Wednesday, with some clinics poised to lift a hold on certain IVF services as early as this week after an unprecedented state Supreme Court ruling threw the future of infertility care into turmoil.

Contents
IVF patients express cautious reliefWhen will services start up again?The case at the heart of the ruling

The new law does not address the issue of personhood at the heart of last month’s unprecedented ruling in a case stemming from the accidental destruction of frozen embryos at a fertility clinic, and experts say it’s going to take more work to protect fertility services in the state. The fertility clinic at the center of that case has halted services and told CNN the new legislation falls short of providing the legal protection it needs to resume care.

The state court ruled frozen embryos are human beings and those who destroy them can be held liable for wrongful death, spurring a national reckoning with reproductive health freedom and IVF access.

Three of the state’s limited pool of IVF providers immediately paused some services, sending some families out of state to access treatment and raising concerns that costs for fertility services would skyrocket.

The Republican-backed legislation, which passed both the Alabama House and Senate late Wednesday before Ivey signed it into law, aims to provide civil and criminal immunity to providers and patients for the destruction or damage to embryos. The legislation will apply retroactively.

“The law does not nullify the Supreme Court’s analysis that says the law ought to treat embryos just like people,” Katherine Kraschel, an assistant professor at Northeastern University School of Law, told CNN on Tuesday.

She noted there “is a lot of ambiguity in the language” in the legislation “that if I was advising a clinic, would give me great pause before resuming treatment.”

She pointed out that the legislation’s wording does not clearly define what falls under in vitro fertilization services, leading to a question about the storage and transportation of embryos.

Experts have also expressed concern that while the legislation protects providers from liability when it comes to the destruction of embryos, it could also insulate them from standard medical malpractice claims.

State Sen. Larry Stutts, a Republican and the lone lawmaker who voted against the measure in the state senate, criticized the language in the bill, arguing it is “not an IVF protection bill, it’s an IVF provider and supplier protection bill” that is “limiting the ability of the mothers that are involved in IVF to have recourse.”

Rep. Terri Collins and Sen. Tim Melson, who introduced the legislation, have noted that it was intended to provide immediate relief for families who have lost access to IVF services, while officials consider more permanent solutions.

“This addresses the imminent problem and that is what I am trying to do today. Do we need to have the longer decision? Yes, we do,” Collins said Thursday.

“This is the temporary fix,” Melson said Thursday during discussion about the legislation on the floor. “This gets the ladies now currently in the situation, that are in limbo, back in the clinic.”

Gov. Ivey similarly acknowledged that the new law was a quick fix after the court ruling and noted that there will be more work to come on IVF protections.

“I am pleased to sign this important, short-term measure into law so that couples in Alabama hoping and praying to be parents can grow their families through IVF,” Ivey said in a statement late Wednesday. “IVF is a complex issue, no doubt, and I anticipate there will be more work to come, but right now, I am confident that this legislation will provide the assurances our IVF clinics need and will lead them to resume services immediately.”

IVF patients express cautious relief

Elizabeth Goldman was in a state of limbo as her IVF treatments were halted. The uterus transplant recipient, who sold her home and moved to Birmingham to start a family, said she was thankful to lawmakers for coming together quickly and helping clinics reopen.

“This has been an extremely stressful and scary 2 1/2 weeks waiting in limbo while my IVF clinic has been shutdown,” Goldman, saying she’d watched every step of the legislation’s passing and now feels hopeful her “journey can continue after my clinic reopens.”

Gabrielle Goidel expressed a sincere sense of relief after the new law was signed.

“Spencer and I just started crying,” she said of her husband. Goidel invested more than $20,000 into IVF after three miscarriages, but the court ruling halted treatment.

Although it doesn’t take away from all the hurt and craziness we felt, it feels like we are finally seeing change and feeling supported, she said. “I feel immense relief and hope.”

Gabbie Price, who uprooted her life and career to afford IVF, told CNN she was comforted knowing some clinics would start treatment again but more work was needed to ensure this wouldn’t happen again.

“I am thrilled that we are able to get something in place so that clinics can safely operate and patients can continue getting the care they need as well as having access to transfer their embryos out of state,” Price said. “I do agree there is a much larger conversation that needs to be had so that we are not in a situation like this again.”

Time was of the essence, though, she said, and this new law gives her ‘comfort’ in staying with her clinic in Alabama.

There are still a lot of unanswered questions and it will take some navigating, but I am hopeful again.

When will services start up again?

Alabama Fertility, one of the clinics that stopped IVF treatment after the state court’s decision, will resume its services this week.

The clinic cancelled at least 35 frozen embryo transfers in the 12 days after stopping treatments. With patients already scheduled to continue treatment, the group plans to restart IVF treatments as early as Thursday or Friday, according to Dr. Mamie McLean, a doctor with the clinic.

We are hopeful that this bill will provide immediate, complete, and permanent access to IVF treatments in Alabama, as she said. “We cannot wait to celebrate with our patients. Honestly, we can’t wait to do the first embryo transfer, we can’t wait to see the first positive pregnancy test … it holds even more meaning than it did before.”

McLean joined families and other IVF advocates at the Alabama State House last week to call for an immediate restoration of services, as lawmakers inside rushed to push through legislation that would protect them.

We appreciate the efforts of the legislators to push through a bill that meets the needs of all stakeholders involved in IVF treatments in Alabama, said McLean. “We are grateful that they have heard our voices. We are proud of our patients who have bravely shared their stories and are so impressed with the advocacy efforts on behalf of infertility patients.

The state’s largest health care system, the University of Alabama at Birmingham, which also paused fertility services after the state court’s decision, said it would also resume IVF treatments but added it would “continue to assess developments,” according to university spokesperson Hannah Echols.

The Center for Reproductive Medicine at Mobile Infirmary, the defendants in the state Supreme Court case, will not be restarting IVF services, as stated by the infirmary.

“As we understand the language of the proposed law, as it stands, we are not reopening our IVF facility until we have legal clarification on the extent of immunity provided by the new Alabama law,” the statement said. “At this time, we believe the law falls short of addressing the fertilized eggs currently stored across the state and leaves challenges for physicians and fertility clinics trying to help deserving families have children of their own.”

The American Society for Reproductive Medicine released a statement Thursday warning that without legislation to address the issue of whether a fertilized egg is legally considered a person, IVF providers are still vulnerable.

“We believe these bills will not provide the assurances Alabama’s fertility physicians need to be confident they can continue to provide the best standard of care to their patients without putting themselves, their colleagues, and their patients at legal risk,” the statement read.

The case at the heart of the ruling

The Alabama Supreme Court ruling stems from two lawsuits filed by three sets of parents who underwent IVF procedures to have babies and then opted to have the remaining embryos frozen.

The parents allege that several frozen embryos were dropped on the floor and destroyed in 2020 at an Alabama fertility clinic and have sued the clinic. The claims were initially dismissed by a trial court, but a state Supreme Court ruling reversed that decision.

A fourth lawsuit has been filed against the defendants in the case since then.

Although the new legislation applies retroactively, it is likely that it won’t impact the case, as the Alabama Constitution states that new legislation cannot be applied to active cases.

Groups representing defendants in the lawsuits that culminated in the Supreme Court ruling that frozen embryos are children have filed an application asking the court to rehear the case, according to online records from the Alabama appellate courts.

The group is asking the court to reconsider their ruling, though the justices could take more than six weeks before deciding whether to grant the application to rehear the case, an Alabama court source.

Legal experts are sceptical about the court’s decision to rehear the case.

Even though some clinics are planning to resume their services, the court’s decision may still have an impact on families in Alabama in the future, Kraschel said.

Courts, especially in Alabama, could cite the Alabama Supreme Court decision to treat embryos as people in other areas of the law as well, she said.

TAGGED:AlabamaHealthIVFKay IveyUnited States
Share This Article
Facebook Twitter LinkedIn Copy Link Print
Previous Article Flight MH370 Malaysia airlines flight MH 370 theory: one of aviation’s biggest mysteries remains unsolved 10 years.
Next Article Jake Paul is set to face Mike Tyson in a live boxing match on Netflix.

Your Trusted Source for Accurate and Timely Updates!

Our commitment to accuracy, impartiality, and delivering breaking news as it happens has earned us the trust of a vast audience. Stay ahead with real-time updates on the latest events, trends.

Popular Posts

The NCAA says that most of the March Madness brackets are already busted.

March Madness is already exceeding expectations for college basketball enthusiasts. The first round of the…

Kim Kardashian – Age, Height, Biography, Family, Boyfriend, Facts & Life Story.

Kim Kardashian was born (on October 21, 1980), in Los Angeles, California. Kim Kardashian is…

The 24-year-old Thane IT graduate responsible for Yogi Adityanath’s death threat

After an inquiry showed that the SMS was sent from Fatima Khan's number, Mumbai Police…

You Might Also Like

Plane Crash
WorldNews

A Russian military transport plane crashed in flames on takeoff with 15 people aboard, Moscow says.

By
NewsWorld

North Korea Fires Ballistic Missiles as Blinken Visits Seoul.

By Pragya Batu
HealthNewsUnited States

CDC warns of rise in Bacterial infections that could cause meningitis and death.

By Editorial Team
IndiaNewsWorld

Amidst the diplomatic impasse between Canada and India, Justin Trudeau Drops a Bombshell

By Pragya Batu
Repute Today Repute Today
Facebook-f X-twitter Instagram Medium-m Quora Youtube Telegram-plane Whatsapp

Repute Today, Focuses on the What, When, Who and How of a trending story, and helps readers with analyses that go beyond the domain of news.

Company
  • About Us
  • Contact Us
  • Disclaimer
  • Privacy Policy
  • Terms and Conditions!
Trending Now
  • United States
  • India
  • News
  • Health
  • Sports
Download Magazine!
© 2025 Repute Today. All Rights Reserved.
adbanner
AdBlock Detected
Our site is an advertising supported site. Please whitelist to support our site.
Okay, I'll Whitelist