By Will Unwin at the Etihad Stadium – February 5, 2026
Manchester City’s manager Pep Guardiola demonstrated his tactical ingenuity with a bold experiment against Newcastle in the Carabao Cup semi-final second leg, using Omar Marmoush and Antoine Semenyo in unconventional roles to outwit the visitors.
Guardiola has continually adapted his approach over the years, notably reinventing the English game by diminishing the influence of traditional center-backs. However, finding a successor to Erling Haaland remains a persistent challenge, given the Norwegian’s extraordinary goal-scoring record and physical presence.
In the match, City’s first goal was scored by Marmoush, who was deployed in a different role to maximize his speed and agility. Operating on the left, Marmoush linked up with Reijnders and Semenyo, creating chaos in Newcastle’s defense with fluid attacking movements. The tactical shift saw City adopting a more artistic, fast-paced approach, rather than relying solely on traditional long balls aimed at Haaland.
The plan paid dividends as City’s attacking fluidity caused confusion in Newcastle’s backline. Marmoush’s clever interplay with Reijnders led to a goal, while his pace and awareness helped set up a second, both illustrating City’s inventive approach. Newcastle struggled to contain the new-look front four, with the pace and movement pulling their defenders out of position.
Despite Haaland’s presence later in the game, he was deployed on the right flank rather than through the middle, showcasing Guardiola’s commitment to tactical flexibility. His best chance, a fine save from Ramsdale, came from a through ball that dissected Newcastle’s defense.
Guardiola’s experiment highlights City’s evolving strategy—moving away from predictability and forcing opponents to adapt. With City now set for an Arsenal final, the innovative tactics employed may serve as a blueprint for future matches, allowing City to manage Haaland’s workload while maintaining attacking surprise.
City fans can expect more surprises ahead as Guardiola continues to refine his approach to keep opponents guessing.