The petitioners stated they were “after strenuous efforts” sent copies of the complaints through their counsel, in connection with past charges lodged against them with the Economic Crimes Wing.
The Bombay High Court on Thursday imposed a personal cost of Rs 25,000 on the station house officer of Wada police station in Palghar for repeated cases of the police refusing to give copies of complaints to accused individuals despite prior instructions by courts.
The division bench of Acting Chief Justice Ravindra V Ghuge and Justice Gautam A Ankhad said such petitions keep coming to the court since authorities do not follow the stated legal standards.
The bench, in a ruling on a request by the accused in an economic crimes case, filed through Advocates Manuj Borkar and Prasad Borkar, observed that the Maharashtra Government’s lawyer “cannot explain the refusal”.
“This court has passed several orders in such matters. We still get such petitions and the petitioners are forced to not only knock on the doors of this court but also spend on litigation,” the bench remarked.
The court further ordered the SHO of Wada Police Station to deposit the sum from his pay account within 15 days. It also disposed of the plea seeking him to provide copies of complaints registered against the petitioners within five working days.
Petitioners claim repeated refusal by police
The petitioners submitted before the court that they were handed copies of the complaints through their counsel in respect of past charges recorded against them with the Economic Crimes Wing (EOW) “after strenuous efforts”.
But yet another crime was lodged against them at Wada Police Station in Palghar district and notifications were issued to them by the SHO.
The petitioners said that when they stood before the Wada Police Station and demanded copies of the complaints against them, a police inspector reportedly informed them they were engaged in “time killing” and refused to produce the papers.
Petitioners cite legal right to complaint copies
The petitioners stated the police had a legal obligation to give the accused information on the charges levelled against them and facilitate the proper exercise of their legal rights.
